Football players in the John Carrigan Rotary South All-Star Classic that have gone on to NFL careers
| Name | Game Year | High School | NFL Teams |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sammy Watkins | 2010 | South Fort Myers | Buffalo Bills |
| Aaron Lynch | 2010 | Island Coast | San Francisco 49ers |
| Tre Boston | 2009 | North Fort Myers | Carolina Panthers |
| Jaylen Watkins | 2009 | Cape Coral | Philadelphia Eagles |
| Tommy Bohanon | 2008 | North Fort Myers | New York Jets |
| Quinton Pointer | 2005 | Mariner | St. Louis Rams |
| Nate Allen | 2005 | Cape Coral | Philadelphia Eagles |
| Jeremy Ware | 2004 | Lehigh | Oakland Raiders and Chicago Bears |
| Edward Gant | 2004 | Cape Coral | Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Arizona Cardinals |
| Taurus Johnson | 2004 | Cape Coral | Kansas City Chiefs; Detroit Lions; Miami Dolphins; Hartford Colonials and Washington Redskins |
| Micah Rucker | 2003 | Estero | Pittsburgh Steelers; Kansas City Chiefs and New York Giants |
| Corey Lynch | 2002 | ECS | Cincinnati Bengals and Tampa Bay Buccaneers |
| Matt Prater | 2001 | Estero | Detroit Lions and Denver Broncos |
| Phillip Buchanon | 1998 | Lehigh | Oakland Raiders; Houston Texans; Tampa Bay Buccaneers; Detroit Lions and Washington Redskins |
| Earnest Graham | 1997 | Mariner | Tampa Bay Buccaneers |
| Anthony Henry | 1995 | Estero | Cleveland Browns; Dallas Cowboys and Detroit Lions |
| Jevon Kearse | 1994 | North | Tennessee Titans and Philadelphia Eagles |
| Greg Spires | 1992 | Mariner | New England Patriots; Cleveland Browns and Tampa Bay Buccaneers |
| Jammi German | 1992 | Fort Myers | Atlanta Falcons and Cleveland Browns |